Both acne care systems have their advantages over the other, and both also have weaknesses and shortcomings.

Murad vs ProActiv

People have been using both systems for years, hoping against hope to be delivered from their acne sufferings, and some have found the results they were searching for.

Still others of us are in the process of finding a product that will work for them. For these people, let’s see how the fight turns out. Then we might have a better idea of which system may be right for us.

Ladies and gentlemen, let’s get ready to rumble! It’s Murad vs Proactiv!

Murad or Proactiv: A Closer Comparison

To get below the surface of this debate, let’s take a look at consumer reviews for both products and see which has the best pros and the worst cons. Then we may be a step or two closer to making the decision of who wins in the battle: Murad vs Proactiv.

Murad Pros:

• Instant Success – While a lot of similar products seem to take forever (if ever at all) to work, there are some consumers who have claimed that Murad worked for them almost instantly.
• Fresh Feel – A lot of people say that the Murad cleanser leaves your skin feeling fresh and smooth.

Murad Cons:

• Burning Sensation – The exfoliating gel tends to make people feel like their faces are on fire. This was a big drawback with the online consumer review community. A health and beauty product should never be as painful as this.
• Irritates Skin – People with sensitive skin have found that the process of using Murad irritates their skin to no end, leaving it flaky, red, and horribly dry.

Proactiv Pros:

• Skin Smoother – Many consumers found that where they didn’t have acne on their faces, the skin became nice and smooth.
• Acne Blaster – While a lot of consumers may be less than enthused about Proactiv’s ability to eliminate acne, some people have had very positive results with as much as 80% of their skin clearing up completely.

Proactiv Cons:

• Overpowering Smell – One of the biggest negative results of using Proactiv, according to many online consumer reviews, is that it gives your skin a terrible odor.
• Flaky Skin – Quite a few consumers have found that after using Proactiv’s line of products, their skin has become red, dry, and awfully flaky. This is a big con.

Is Murad Better Than Proactiv?

That’s a good question. While they both have decent benefits and advantages, they also have terrible downsides.

So, in order to make this final decision, we have to go to the online consumer review community. Because while no single product will ever be the favorite of everyone who uses it, the review community will let you know (by way of the average scores for certain products) whether or not a lotion, moisturizer, or skin care system is worthy of your time to explore further.

So what does the community say?

They say that while they both have their upsides and downsides, it is Murad that people have been happier with.

Proactiv definitely has its benefits, but in the end, the battle royale of Murad vs Proactiv ends with…

A Murad victory!

Return from Murad vs Proactiv to Murad Moisturizer Reviews

Return from Murad vs Proactiv to Best Moisturizers: Reviews & Ratings

I recently purchased Murad Essential-C Day Moisture SPF 15 because it is summer time and I needed sun protection. Instead of just buying a regular sunscreen I decided to purchase a moisturizer that also had a good level of SPF. I have purchased Murad products in the past, and I purchased Murad Essential-C Day Moisture SPF 15 with confidence.

This moisturizer smells wonderful. I cannot really explain the scent, but it is wonderfully pleasant and revitalizing. I really enjoyed the texture of Murad Essential-C Day Moisture SPF 15 on my skin. After applying this lotion, my skin felt wonderfully refreshed. Usually sunscreen leaves my skin too greasy and makes my skin breakout. With Murad’s moisturizer, I noticed an improvement in my skin. After using the moisturizer for a couple of weeks I noticed that my skin tone became more even.

I think that Murad Essential-C Day Moisture SPF 15 is great for use on the face. After using this on my face I had fewer breakouts. I think that this may be a little too oily for the face. When using this moisturizer I do need to apply a little more powder than usual. I use this all over my body and it absorbs pretty quickly. The formula is quite light and very easy to apply. There are many great skin benefits I noticed when using this Murad moisturizer. My skin looked much brighter after only a few days of use. It is so wonderful to have a great moisturizer and not have to worry about using additional sun protection.

When using Murad Essential-C Day Moisture SPF 15 I did not need to apply any more of the moisturizer all day. This is a pretty strong moisturizer that lasts for many hours. This is a great product, and it does a wonderful job of hydrating my skin. There are antioxidants in this moisturizer, and my skin feels and looks much younger since using this product. I have received many compliments on my skin. This would be an even better product if it contained SPF 30 instead of only SPF 15. Nevertheless, even though this product is almost $60 for a small tube, it is a great buy.

Murad Essential-C Day Moisture SPF 15 improved my skin within days. I didn’t expect this little moisturizer to make such a difference in my skin. I am very pleased with my purchase and would definitely recommend this to others.

Return to Best Moisturizer Reviews and Ratings

By: Avery Bennett

Murad is a line that uses moisture as the basis for all its skin-care products. Dr. Howard Murad, a renowned dermatologist, spent years performing research based on the science of cellular water to create this skincare line. Murad makes products for people with acne and other skincare problems, as well as daily creams, hydration serums, and other products for daily skin care.

Murad’s Perfecting Day Cream sells for about $45 dollars for a 1.7 oz. tube. The moisturizer is a bit on the heavy side, and having combination skin, I thought it may be a touch heavy for my daily use. I was wrong. This cream is heavy, but sinks right into the skin, not leaving any trace of oil or shine. In fact, the Perfecting Cream left a matte finish on my face and helped my powder foundation stick well. The creme doesn’t have much of a fragrance, which is nice for a face moisturizer. It only takes a small amount to cover the entire face, and sinks in quickly, so it doesn’t require a lot of the product for daily use. I found that the hydrating properties of Murad’s Perfecting Cream were immediately noticeable, as the fine lines plumped out of my skin, and my cheeks seemed more filled out. The creme sunk in well to the skin, so it left the face well-moisturized throughout the day, and I never noticed any sliding of my makeup at all.

The Perfecting Cream is also an SPF 30, so it protects the face and neck from the sun quite well. This was a nice bonus, as I have found many SPF creams to be oily, thick, and usually led to breakouts on my face. The Perfecting Cream is heavy, but not oily, nor causes breakouts, so it’s the perfect combination moisturizer for those customers who would rather use just one product rather than three. I’ve found Murad’s Perfecting Creme to serve well as a moisturizer, makeup primer, and a sun block.

According to the Murad Web site, the Perfecting Cream uses Evening Primrose, Borage Seed Oil, and Essential Fatty Acids to aid in retaining moisture in the face. Lecithin is used to help restore the skin’s supple nature and also to lock in moisture. Finally, Soy Flour is used in the Perfecting Cream to help soften lines and protect elasticity in the skin.

Murad suggests using the complimentary cleanser and toner prior to applying the Perfecting Day Cream to the face and neck. I used my general, cheap, drugstore facial cleanser, no toner, and then applied the Perfecting Day Cream to my face and had no problem. I found this to be one of the best moisturizers on the market, and it warrants the price, as it lasts a long time.

Return to Best Moisturizer Reviews and Ratings

By: Sari Hardyal